The difference between CVT and AT, which one is superior?
JAKARTA – The debate about the type of transmission that is most suitable for daily needs and long distance travel is still ongoing. Some people feel that CVT transmission is smoother and more efficient, while others consider conventional automatic transmission (AT) much more resilient.
According to Prijodie Amdhani, one of the JMW Motor Transmission Specialist Workshop Technician Werke, the character of driving and the terrain that is often traversed is an important factor in determining the choice of transmission. For drivers who like to drive a car at high speed, the AT transmission is considered more appropriate.
“The AT transmission is being chased by the torque. Want to endurance? Use AT,” said Jodie when met at his workshop located at Pasar Fresh Cinere, recently.
He explained that the AT transmission has advantages in durability and the ability to deliver torque, especially when carried in heavy conditions such as steep inclines or mountain paths. Therefore, for daily use that often crosses the highlands, AT is more recommended.
“CVT transmission is not created to climb. Bring it to Dieng or Wonosobo, it must be difficult if you use CVT, it will be hot. Use AT in Wonosobo, strong,” said Jodie.
In addition, Jodie emphasized that the AT transmission has better resistance than CVT when it comes to endurance. According to him, the design of the CVT is indeed more suitable for urban cars that do not face heavy conditions on the road.
“CVT transmission is not a compound when it comes to resilience. CVT is ideal for city cars or cars whose operations are in urban areas,” said Jodie.
In other words, the choice of transmission remains back to the needs and field of use. However, for users who prioritize performance and toughness in various road conditions, AT transmission is a safer and more durable option.
Advantages of AT transmission
- Better durability: AT transmission is designed to handle heavy loads and extreme conditions, such as steep terrain or mountain paths. This makes it more suitable for daily use that often traverses highland areas.
- ability to distribute torque: AT transmission is able to channel torque better, especially in situations that require extra power, such as when facing inclines or heavy loads.
- Long term resistance: Compared to CVT, AT transmission tends to be more durable, especially in intensive and diverse use conditions.
Advantages of CVT transmission
- more smooth and efficient: CVT transmission is generally smoother in operation and more efficient in fuel use, especially in urban environments.
- Suitable for urban cars: Its light and responsive design makes CVT very suitable for cars used in urban areas, where the roads are relatively flat and not too heavy.
- reduce noise: Because it does not have a manual moving gear, CVT can provide a more calm and comfortable driving experience.
Recommendations based on need
The choice of transmission must be adjusted to the needs of the user and the condition of the road that is often traversed. If the user often travels long distances or passes through rough terrain, then the AT transmission is a more appropriate choice. However, for users who drive more often in the city and prioritize comfort and efficiency, CVT can be a more suitable alternative.
Conclusion
In general, AT transmission is superior in terms of toughness and durability, especially in heavy conditions. Meanwhile, CVT is more suitable for daily use in urban environments. Therefore, vehicle owners need to consider the needs and road conditions that they often pass before choosing the type of transmission to be used.
